Rubric

Keep in mind that 33 students have already been assessed using this rubric. Changing it will affect their evaluations.
Student: Use this rubric to give feedback on the proposal
Student: Use this rubric to give feedback on the proposal
Criteria Ratings Pts
Values in the plan: This proposal specifically mentions the intrinsic value of:
threshold: pts
10 pts humans
9 pts animals (individual animals)
8 pts ecosystems or species
7 pts plants
6 pts one or more of these things
5 pts none
pts
10 pts
--
This proposal specifically mentions the instrumental value of:
threshold: pts
10 pts humans
9 pts animals (individual animals)
8 pts ecosystems or species
7 pts plants (either individuals or species)
6 pts one or more of these things
5 pts none of these things
pts
10 pts
--
Environmental Justice in the Plan: Does this proposal specifically mention traditionally marginalized groups?
threshold: pts
2 pts no
1 pts yes
pts
2 pts
--
Does this plan specifically mention a way to put members of traditionally marginalized groups in charge of the decisions that affect them directly?
threshold: pts
10 pts yes
9 pts no
8 pts not sure
pts
10 pts
--
Will this proposal, if successful, direct the harms and benefits so that the people who get the benefits also deal with the harms, or will the benefits go to one group of people and the costs or harms fall disproportionately on a different group of people?
threshold: pts
10 pts Harms and benefits all go to same group of people
9 pts hard to tell
8 pts Benefits go mostly to one group, while costs and harms fall disproportionally on a different group of people
pts
10 pts
--
Relationship between humans and nature in the plan: In this proposal, are humans seen as a part of nature, or separate?
threshold: pts
10 pts Both
9 pts Part of nature
8 pts Separate
7 pts neither
6 pts hard to say
pts
10 pts
--
In this proposal, are humans actions portrayed as a positive force, a negative force, or both?
threshold: pts
10 pts both
9 pts positive force
8 pts negative force
7 pts neither
6 pts hard to say
pts
10 pts
--
Possibility for success: Does this proposal mention the success (and lessons) from other people, or does it start from scratch?
threshold: pts
1 pts Builds on the work of others
0.5 pts a mix
0 pts Starts at the beginning
pts
1 pts
--
Can the goals in this proposal be feasibly reached by the end of the quarter?
threshold: pts
10 pts yes
9 pts No, but the writer recognizes that
8 pts no
7 pts maybe/hard to say
pts
10 pts
--
If this proposal succeeds, will it have made progress (no matter how small or big) toward important goals of sustainability?
threshold: pts
10 pts yes
9 pts no
8 pts maybe/hard to say
pts
10 pts
--